Professor Calls Fitness a Tool of ‘FASCISM’

Man lifting kettlebell in gym
Photo: Ground Picture / Shutterstock

The fight over “fitness” isn’t about gyms and gadgets; it’s about who gets to define normal bodies, assign virtue to discipline, and wield those judgments in institutions that shape opportunity and dignity.

At a Glance

  • An NPR interview with University of Michigan scholar Ava Purkiss argues that fitness ideals and metrics can be mobilized as “soft fascism,” linking the language of bodily “fitness” to historical projects of hierarchy and control.
  • BMI, the most ubiquitous body metric, originated as a population-statistics tool, not an individual diagnostic, which limits its clinical precision across diverse groups.
  • Scholarly literature documents weight stigma’s measurable health harms and its uneven impact across racial and ethnic lines.
  • Public health guidance remains clear that physical activity and strength training improve health outcomes; the tension lies not in whether exercise helps, but in how society moralizes bodies and enforces standards.

What the claim is—and what it isn’t

During an NPR Code Switch conversation framed as “Why Fascists Love ‘Fitness’,” Ava Purkiss, an associate professor of Women’s and Gender Studies, connected modern fitness rhetoric to older classificatory regimes—eugenics foremost—that sorted people into “fit” and “unfit.” Her argument was not that exercise is harmful or that strength is undesirable; it was that institutionalized judgments about fitness, discipline, and body size can be conscripted to rank bodies and justify exclusion under a sheen of health and virtue. The phrase “soft fascism” signals a cultural and bureaucratic project—less jackboots than checklists—that normalizes who belongs, who is praiseworthy, and who is a problem to be managed.

This line of analysis lives alongside, not against, a robust medical consensus that physical activity improves cardiometabolic health, muscular function, and longevity. Global and U.S. guidelines repeatedly endorse regular aerobic and resistance exercise for broad health gains, including better blood pressure, glycemic control, lipid profiles, and physical function. The debate is over the social uses of “fitness”—how we define, measure, and reward it—not the physiology of training.

How BMI became a gatekeeper

To understand how an apparently neutral number acquires moral weight, start with BMI’s biography. The index traces back to Adolphe Quetelet’s 19th-century effort to describe the “average man”—a population-statistics project, not a clinical instrument to size up an individual’s health. Its modern thresholds emerged through 20th-century institutional standardization and insurance data, reflecting convenience and comparability as much as biology. That origin matters because BMI presumes a stable relationship between height, weight, and adiposity that varies by sex, age, and ethnicity; as a surrogate measure, it can misclassify muscular bodies and obscure differences in fat distribution and risk profiles across populations.

Public health researchers have long debated BMI’s value as a screening tool: useful at scale, noisier in the exam room. Reviews and position papers increasingly urge complementary measures—waist circumference, body composition, clinical markers—when assessing individual risk. The point is not that BMI is inherently prejudicial; it’s that when a coarse metric becomes a gatekeeper for care, employment, or insurance, its errors and blind spots can concentrate disadvantage—especially where obesity prevalence and cardiometabolic risk already reflect structural inequities.

From measurement to moral judgment

Metrics do not stigmatize on their own; people and systems do. Yet weight stigma is well documented and consequential. A scoping review linking weight discrimination to 25 physical and mental health outcomes underscores that bias itself is a health hazard—independent of body mass—via stress pathways, delayed care, and reduced physical activity participation. When stereotypes about discipline, willpower, or citizenship attach to body size, those judgments fall unevenly across racial and socioeconomic lines, in part because disparities in obesity and related conditions are themselves shaped by neighborhood environments, food access, work schedules, pollution exposure, and chronic stressors rooted in policy, not personal virtue.

Historians of sport and physical education have shown how standards of “healthy bodies” were taught as civic ideals—who counted as fully fit for public life and who needed reform or exclusion. That legacy does not indict modern training or health promotion; it clarifies how fitness talk can slide into social sorting when numbers become moral verdicts and when “discipline” is coded as proof of character.

Does “soft fascism” fit?

Purkiss’s provocation forces a hard question: when do health norms harden into ideological instruments? The term “soft fascism” is interpretive, not clinical. It points to cultural projects that naturalize hierarchy—where “fitness” rhetoric legitimizes coercion, shaming, or differential access to rights and resources without overt authoritarian trappings. The historical record connects bodily “fitness” to eugenic sorting; contemporary practice connects weight stigma to measurable harms; BMI’s origin and limitations explain why a single metric, deployed crudely, can amplify bias.

Reasonable people will differ on the label. Some will argue the phrase overreaches and obscures the public health mission. Others will counter that strong language properly names a pattern too easily sanitized as “wellness.” The underlying evidence supports three sober claims: BMI is a blunt instrument with uneven accuracy across populations; weight stigma damages health and access to care; and fitness norms have historically been used to police citizenship and belonging. Whether one adopts Purkiss’s term or not, those three claims hold.

Reconciling the physiology with the politics

There is no contradiction between protecting people from stigma and promoting strength, capacity, and function. Exercise physiology is clear: regular movement and, critically, resistance training improve strength, balance, insulin sensitivity, and quality of life across the lifespan, including for people managing chronic disease. A health-forward approach keeps that science at the center while changing how institutions talk about and operationalize it: emphasize function over form, tailor assessment beyond BMI alone, remove punitive gatekeeping, and build environments where active lives are feasible for shift workers, caregivers, and communities facing resource constraints.

This has practical consequences. Clinicians can pair BMI with waist measures and metabolic labs; employers can decouple wellness incentives from scale numbers and focus on participation and functional gains; educators can teach physical literacy without body shaming; policymakers can invest in safe streets and parks rather than moralizing individual willpower. The aim is fitness as capacity and autonomy, not as a cudgel.

What this means going forward

Purkiss’s critique lands because it targets a real slippage: from risk screening to social ranking. The remedy is not to abandon metrics or exercise but to be precise about what measurements mean, where they fail, and how institutions can support health without policing bodies. Keep the science of training; retire the moral theater. When fitness is framed as a shared capability—measured with nuance, pursued without stigma—it ceases to be a proxy for virtue and becomes what it should be: a public good.

Sources:

thegatewaypundit.com, pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov, ahajournals.org, ncbi.nlm.nih.gov