An anonymous caller to SiriusXM’s conservative talk show declared transgenderism a “mental illness” while describing his detransition experience, providing fresh ammunition for advocates pushing to restrict gender-affirming medical care nationwide.
Story Highlights
- Anonymous male caller tells Andrew Wilkow he’s detransitioning and regrets medical interventions
- Caller labels transgenderism as “mental illness” contradicting major medical associations
- Conservative media amplifies story to support restrictions on gender-affirming care
- Timing aligns with ongoing state-level battles over youth transition treatments
Detransitioner Shares Regret on National Radio
During a December 19th episode of “The Wilkow Majority” on SiriusXM Patriot, an anonymous male caller revealed his decision to detransition after previously identifying as transgender. The caller expressed deep regret about medical interventions he underwent, telling host Andrew Wilkow that identifying as transgender failed to resolve his underlying psychological issues. His testimony provides real-world evidence of the dangers conservatives have long warned about regarding rushed gender transitions.
Medical Establishment’s Narrative Challenged
The caller’s blunt assessment that transgenderism constitutes a “mental illness” directly contradicts the position of major medical organizations like the American Psychiatric Association and American Medical Association. These institutions removed gender identity disorder from mental health classifications in 2013, replacing it with “gender dysphoria” to reduce stigma. However, this caller’s lived experience suggests the medical establishment may have prioritized political correctness over patient welfare, leaving individuals like him to suffer the consequences of inadequate psychological evaluation.
Research indicates detransition rates remain in the low single digits, but methodological differences and political pressures may obscure higher actual rates. Common reasons for detransition include health complications from treatments, realization that underlying mental health issues weren’t addressed, and regret over irreversible changes. The caller’s testimony aligns with these patterns, highlighting how current gender-affirming care protocols may rush patients toward medical interventions without proper psychological screening.
Conservative Media Amplifies Cautionary Tale
The Daily Caller and other conservative outlets quickly picked up the story, recognizing its value in ongoing battles over youth gender-affirming care. This caller’s experience mirrors testimony from other detransitioners like Chloe Cole, who have appeared before state legislatures to support bills restricting transition treatments for minors. These personal accounts provide compelling evidence that current medical protocols prioritize ideological compliance over patient safety, particularly for vulnerable young people.
The timing proves significant as multiple Republican-led states have enacted or considered legislation banning puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries for minors. Detransitioner testimony has become crucial evidence supporting these protections, demonstrating real-world harm from rushed gender transitions. The anonymous caller’s story adds another powerful voice to this growing chorus of individuals warning about the dangers of gender-affirming care without proper safeguards.
Protecting Children From Irreversible Harm
This case underscores the urgent need for stricter oversight of gender transition protocols, especially for minors who cannot fully comprehend long-term consequences. The caller’s regret about medical interventions highlights how current informed consent processes may inadequately prepare patients for potential negative outcomes. Enhanced psychological evaluation and mandatory waiting periods could prevent future cases of detransition regret, protecting vulnerable individuals from life-altering decisions made during periods of mental distress.
Sources:
Caller Tells SiriusXM’s Andrew Wilkow He’s Detransitioning, Calls Transgenderism ‘Mental Illness’
Caller Tells SiriusXM’s Andrew Wilkow He’s Detransitioning, Calls Transgenderism ‘Mental Illness’
Previous Shows – Andrew Wilkow
